New Zealand Is Getting A Little Too Friendly With China

Introduction: A Disguise of Kindness

New Zealand has long presented itself as a liberal democracy, known for its progressive values and commitment to human rights. Former Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, in particular, gained global recognition as a liberal icon, advocating for a "politics of kindness." However, when it comes to its relationship with China, New Zealand seems to have a different set of values.

A Reluctance to Speak Out

Despite Ardern's claims of empathy and kindness, her track record on calling out China for its human rights abuses is dismal. New Zealand released statements expressing "concern" about China's treatment of Uyghurs in Xinjiang, but fell short of using stronger language or taking any significant action.

Moreover, New Zealand bowed out of a joint statement condemning arrests in Hong Kong under the National Security Law, and even removed references to "genocide" from a motion on Uyghur persecution. It seems that New Zealand is more concerned with maintaining its cozy relationship with China than standing up for human rights.

The China Problem Runs Deeper

New Zealand's reluctance to confront China is not limited to human rights issues. The country has become increasingly dependent on China, both economically and politically. China is New Zealand's largest trading partner, with agricultural products like meat and dairy making up a significant portion of its exports.

New Zealand's ties to China have caused concerns within the intelligence sharing network called the Five Eyes, which includes the US, UK, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. New Zealand has been considered a weak link in the network due to its susceptibility to Chinese influence and potential compromise.

China's Grasp on New Zealand

New Zealand's problematic relationship with China extends beyond trade. Former Prime Minister Bill English, from the conservative National Party, signed New Zealand up for China's Belt and Road Initiative, despite concerns about the potential risks and traps associated with the program.

Furthermore, New Zealand supported China's membership into the World Trade Organization, a decision that has had detrimental effects on the global economy. China's central role in New Zealand's economy makes it difficult for the country to take a strong stance against Chinese aggression or human rights abuses.

Conclusion: A Difficult Position

New Zealand finds itself in a challenging position. Its close ties to China, both economically and politically, have created a reluctance to speak out against the Chinese regime. The country's dependence on China for trade and its fragile economy further complicate matters.

It remains to be seen whether New Zealand will be willing to take a stronger stance against China in the future. The country's reputation as a liberal democracy and advocate for human rights hangs in the balance. Perhaps it's time for New Zealand to reconsider its alliances and prioritize its values over economic gains.