What Joe Goldberg Said To Phoebe In You Season 4

In the opening episode of You Season 4, we were introduced to Joe's interaction with a group of elites who became central to the unfolding story throughout the season. In episode 2, we heard Phoebe express that something Joe said to her had a profound impact on her. She mentioned how she had never been seen so clearly by anyone before, and it felt like destiny had brought them together as friends. However, the show never revealed what Joe actually said to Phoebe that night, leaving us with an unanswered question. So, let's dive into some speculation and explore what Joe might have said to Phoebe and why we never got a concrete answer in the show.

The Mystery of Joe's Words to Phoebe

Lady Phoebe, a main supporting character in Season 4, was portrayed as someone who was often exploited by her boyfriend and fiancé, Adam. People saw her only through the lens of the articles written about her and the betrayal she experienced from the press. However, as the season progressed, we discovered that Phoebe was different from the rest of the group. She wanted to do good in her life and help others, as evidenced by her decision to teach English to children in Thailand.

When Joe was first introduced to Kate's friends at the club, Phoebe was one of the first people he spoke to. But this initial conversation does not hold the key to our quest for information. It was later in the episode, when Joe was in a state of drinking and socializing, that he had a conversation with Phoebe. She was in tears and being comforted by Kate, and Joe seemed surprised to find himself speaking to her. What's even more puzzling is that she appeared deeply upset, as if he had said something hurtful rather than something that made her feel seen.

The Possibilities of What Joe Said

There are a few possible explanations for what Joe might have said to Phoebe. One intriguing possibility is that he spoke about her experience of being stalked throughout her life. During the opening episode, we saw glimpses of news articles flashing on the screen, highlighting instances of Phoebe being stalked. Given Joe's penchant for research and his own history as a serial stalker, it's plausible that he tapped into this commonality, understanding what it's like to communicate with someone who has been victimized. This could have allowed Phoebe to feel a connection with Joe, believing that he saw her in a way that no one else had before.

Another possibility is that Joe and Phoebe discussed his feelings for Marion. In an earlier conversation with Malcolm, Joe passionately talked about Marion and how they were perfect together. It's conceivable that Joe continued this conversation with Phoebe, especially considering that Malcolm remarked that everyone thought Joe was in London because of love. Joe's infatuation with Marion might have resonated with Phoebe, given her own experiences with Adam. Joe could have provoked strong emotions in her by speaking candidly about her relationship with Adam and revealing uncomfortable truths.

My Personal Theory: Joe and Phoebe's Connection

Personally, I am inclined to believe that the conversation between Joe and Phoebe revolved around her history of being stalked. This would explain her emotional reaction and the sense of being truly seen that she described. Joe's unique understanding of the victim's perspective, combined with his ability to flip the narrative as an attacker, could have created a twisted dynamic of connection between them. This would have shed light on Joe's twisted mind much earlier in the season, rather than waiting until the finale to reveal his manipulations.

Why Wasn't the Answer Revealed?

The fact that the conversation between Joe and Phoebe was never fully addressed in the show, especially in Season 4 Part 2, was likely a deliberate stylistic choice. It wasn't a plot hole, but rather a way to showcase Joe's capacity to be there for people when they need him, even if he doesn't realize it himself. This mirrors his past relationships with Paco and Ellie in earlier seasons. Additionally, the conversation could have been a result of alcohol-induced inhibition, where people often speak about deep topics they later forget or brush aside. It was a moment that happened and vanished, as is often the case in real life.

It's unfortunate that we may never have a definitive answer to what Joe said to Phoebe. However, there is a glimmer of hope for future seasons. With Joe still in a relationship with Kate, who was present and comforting Phoebe during their conversation, it's possible that the topic may resurface and be explored further. Until then, we are left to ponder the possibilities and complexities of their interaction.

In conclusion, the mystery of what Joe said to Phoebe in You Season 4 adds an intriguing layer to the narrative. The show's decision to leave this conversation open-ended allows for speculation and interpretation, reinforcing the twisted and unpredictable nature of Joe's character.